
Mass Effect: We Hardly Knew Ye
So EA killed BioWare and canceled Mass Effect 5.
I was going to mention how long-time readers of would surely know of my love of all things BioWare, but I guess my Mass Effect: Andromeda post never made it out of my Drafts on the old WordPress site and, aside from talking about Veilguard post last year, I guess I talked about playing KOTOR a little bit back in 2004. So no, I guess you wouldn’t necessarily know that.
I loved Mass Effect. I loved the role-playing in it. I loved that my choices (sort of) mattered. I loved the NPC relationships. But mostly, I loved the idea of it. And I think, in the end, I was always just a bit disappointed with it.

Robin D Laws talks about iconic heroes[1], and how they differ from dramatic heroes. Iconic heroes encounter a problem in the world and solve it by adhering to their iconic ethos, thereby restoring the status quo. Sherlock Holmes solves mysteries by noticing things and making deductions. Captain Picard stops a war or escapes the space anomaly with meetings and speeches. Doctor Who makes a clever gadget and then talks the Daleks into blowing themselves up. Story after story.
And generally, the stories are procedural. They’re solving a problem. They’re episodic. Every week, the hero encounters the problem and at the end every week, things go back more or less to where they were at the start. The hero doesn’t appreciably change, because they wouldn’t be iconic if they did. They’re a point of stillness in a changing universe.
Is this old-fashioned? Hell yeah. It’s really hard to find these days. Scriptwriters are allergic to it. Everybody needs a dramatic arc.
Commander Shepard is (or ought to be) an iconic hero. The cool thing is, you get to decide her iconic ethos. Are you a Paragon, or are you a Renegade? The game and the story changes (subtly, admittedly) on which way you choose to go. That’s really cool.
What’s frustrating is the original Mass Effect provides a fantastic premise for an episodic procedural. Shepard is the first human Spectre. She’s a special agent who can go anywhere and do whatever it takes to solve problems and investigate mysteries. What an awesome premise! You got a cool spaceship and a bunch of interesting friends with their own abilities, and you could go around making the galaxy a better place, one slightly on rails combat map at a time! Fun space adventures!
Spoilers for decades-old videogames after the cut.
The actual story of the first Mass Effect didn’t entirely live up to that premise, aside from side quests. Instead, it leaned heavily on the cosmic horror and a galactic threat that will inevitably wipe out everything. Because stakes, I guess.
And, as a reminder, I loved that game. But there was a potential there that I was very excited about. The worldbuilding was fantastic. The characters were great. So I kinda felt this could be another franchise like Star Trek or Star Wars with limitless potential for story.
It’s hard to describe how Mass Effect 2 was such a disappointment for me. Because rather than Shepard just going off having more adventures, we discover that mere weeks after the end of the last game, the Normandy is destroyed and Shepard is killed. They both get rebuilt by some weird fascist cult corporation thing and sent off on some new ultimate threat (which are only a threat to humanity this time, I guess), and we get more cosmic horror and galactic-level stakes.
I know a lot of people dearly love ME2, and it’s clearly a better game, in terms of how it looks and how it plays, but man, maybe we’ll get fun space adventures in Mass Effect 3…?
Haha, no, of course not! The ultimate war to end all advanced life in the galaxy is already underway and there’s nary a fun space adventure to be found. Except for the Citadel DLC. I loved the Citadel DLC.
And because Mass Effect 3 does actually end the galaxy as we know it, one way or another (but you get to choose!), Mass Effect Andromeda heads off to the Andromeda galaxy with less clear worldbuilding and some uncomfortable gestures towards colonialism. It’s an odd game.
And I didn’t hate any of them. I even really enjoyed Andromeda. After a while, I kinda knew Mass Effect wasn’t going to be what I wanted it to be. I just went with it. I didn’t even get upset at the ending to ME3. This is the story they wanted to tell. For some reason it always had to be the whole galaxy at stake every time, and this was just more of that. 🤷
We don’t know what Mass Effect 5 would have been. The end result probably would’ve been full of compromises from studio interference. It’s set hundreds of years after ME3, so no Shepard, but man that trailer is cool. And that line… “Making the choices no one is willing to make, going where others are afraid to go. […] Stopping [the fires] before they start”. I’m sure the cosmic horror and galaxy-destroying stakes would have worked their way into it somehow, but that sounds like fun space adventures to me.
I think in his book Hamlet’s Hit Points, but I’m mostly going from the many times he’s talked about it on his podcast. ↩︎
